• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Big Ideas for Small Business logo

Barbara Weltman

Big Ideas for Small Business, Inc.

Whitepaper download

Subscribe and download our eBook, "150+ Tax Deductions for Small Business A to Z."

This field is hidden when viewing the form
Get the:

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Big Ideas For Your Business
    • Idea Of The Day ®
    • SMB Legal
    • SMB Taxes
    • SMB Financial
    • Small Business
    • Newsletter Archive
  • Services
  • Books
  • Blog
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • Radio Shows/Podcasts
  • Be a Guest Blogger

What Should Congress Do About the QBI Deduction?

October 10, 2024 / By Barbara Weltman

What Should Congress Do About the QBI Deduction?The qualified small business income (QBI) deduction, created by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 as a way for owners of pass-through entities to get a tax break at a time when the corporate rate dropped to 21%, is set to expire on December 31, 2025. If Congress does nothing—doesn’t extend the QBI deduction and retains the 21% corporate tax rate—it means that small business owners could be paying 37% on their profits while the Amazons, the Apples, the Disneys, the McDonalds, the Teslas, and other C corporations regardless of size pay just 21%. Is that fair? Does that make any economic sense? The following are some ideas on how Congress could or should address this issue.

Why extend the QBI deduction?

EY, on behalf of the NFIB, prepared a report entitled Macroeconomic Impacts of Permanently Extending the Section 199A Deduction on Small Businesses. The report found these key economic results of extending the QBI deduction to be:

  • Benefiting US workers through increased labor productivity, wages, and employment
  • Increasing GDP ($75 billion annually, on average, over the first 10 years)

Standard proposals for extension

If Congress decides to extend the QBI deduction, it can be done in several ways:

  • Extend existing law temporarily (e.g., 5 years). A short extension could give Congress more time to create a better, more permanent solution.
  • Make the QBI deduction permanent as it stands now. Owners of pass-through entities will have had 8 years of operating under the current QBI deduction regime, so at least there would be nothing new to learn.
  • Amend the QBI deduction for a temporary or permanent extension. The current regime is highly complicated and bars owners in certain highly profitable service businesses from getting any deduction; they’re paying up to 37% on their share of business income.

Another approach

I submit that there’s an easier way to create tax parity for C corporations and owners of pass-through entities. Let owners pay tax on their profits from pass-through entities at the same tax rate applied to the profits of C corporations.

Why? I think a comparable tax rate, regardless of the legal way in which a business is formed, should be used. It’s fair.

How? Giving separate tax treatment to business income for individuals means breaking out this income so it can be taxed separately. Doing this is nothing new. There are several examples of this:

  • Farming and fishing income currently can be taxed using income averaging.
  • Capital gains and qualified dividends for individuals are subject to special favorable tax rates (zero, 15%, or 20%, depending on an individual’s taxable income).
  • Before the Tax Reform Act of 1986, when individual income tax rates ran as high as 70%, earned income was subject to a maximum rate of 50% (called the “max tax”). The Tax Reform Act of 1969 enacted this 50% limit on personal service income. I don’t want to simplify the max tax; it wasn’t just a 50% limit because deductions had to be allocated between earned and unearned income before applying the max tax rate.

Other matters. Using a uniform tax rate would require Congress to address certain other issues:

  • How to handle losses. Currently, owners of pass-through entities can take those losses on their personal returns—subject to a loss limitation rule that runs through 2028.
  • How to tax small profits. Why should a business owner who has profits that would otherwise be taxed on a personal return at 10% or 15% pay the same 21% rate as large corporations and other highly profitable businesses? They shouldn’t. The tax computation could be structured so that such owners pay up to 21% (i.e., a lower rate if their personal tax bracket warrants it).

Final thought

Members of Congress are continually saying they support small business. Let’s see if this is so.

For more information on the QBI Deduction, see this list of blogs.

Tags Congress QBI deduction small business owners tax deductions

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • General Business (498)
  • Guest Blog (109)
  • Homepage (21)
  • Small Business (990)
  • SMB Financial (322)
  • SMB Legal (66)
  • SMB Taxes (324)

Barbara’s Recent Posts

  • Scale Your Business by Stepping Up IP Protection May 29, 2025
  • Disasters Happen: It’s Important to Be Prepared Now May 27, 2025
  • How Work Order Software Transforms Small Business Operations May 26, 2025
  • The Numbers Are Up for Sole Proprietorships May 22, 2025
  • New Business or Project Crowdfunding: What To Know May 20, 2025
  • Old-School Estimating vs. Smart Solutions: What’s Really Holding You Back? May 19, 2025
  • Employees Getting Called to Public Service: What to Know May 15, 2025
  • Not Too Late to Prep for Summer Now May 13, 2025
  • How Will the Next Generation of Learners Affect the Workplace May 12, 2025
  • Moms Know Best: Lessons for Entrepreneurs May 8, 2025
  • Mental Health Challenges in the Workplace May 6, 2025
  • Let’s Celebrate Small Business! May 1, 2025
Awarded Top 100 Small Business Blog medal (link will open in a new window or tab)
Marquis Who's Who 2023 Badge
Top Small Business Blogs (Link will open in a new window or tab.)
8 Financial blogs small business Owners Need to Read. Invoice home.  (link will open in a new window or tab)
Best Small Business Blog, Expertido.org
Top 50 Small Business Blogs 2018
Best Small Business Blogs
BizHumm Top 100 Business Blog Award to Barbara Weltman
FitsSmallBusiness.com: Award for Best Small Business Blog 2017 (link will open in a new window or tab)
FitsSmallBusiness.com: Award for Best Small Business Blog 2016 (link will open in a new window or tab)

Footer

Big Ideas for Small Business logo

Small business ideas, business tax news and small business consulting from Barbara Weltman to provide business owners with the information they need to succeed. Visit our small business blog, Idea of The Day®, small business books and articles on small business taxes, small business finance and small business legal advice.

Contact Us

[email protected]

(772) 492-9593

gacor maxwin situs slot thailand terpercaya situs slot gacor situs gacor akun pro thailand slot bandar togel terpercaya

Latest Tweets

bigideas4sb Big Ideas for Small Business® @bigideas4sb ·
May 27

Do I Have to Tell External Candidates I’m Considering Someone Internal? — Improve Your HR https://bit.ly/43dscoO #smallbusiness #hiring #workplace

Reply on Twitter 1927477539204710619 Retweet on Twitter 1927477539204710619 Like on Twitter 1927477539204710619 Twitter 1927477539204710619
bigideas4sb Big Ideas for Small Business® @bigideas4sb ·
May 27

A Good Time to Review Your Company’s Driving Policy - https://bit.ly/4lVXNUC #smallbusiness #drivingpolicy #driving

Reply on Twitter 1927462491241562410 Retweet on Twitter 1927462491241562410 Like on Twitter 1927462491241562410 Twitter 1927462491241562410
bigideas4sb Big Ideas for Small Business® @bigideas4sb ·
May 27

Mental Health Challenges in the Workplace - It’s been estimated that nearly 1 in 5 people in the U.S. have a mental health issue https://bit.ly/4jT70LG #workplace #wellness #smallbusiness #wellbeing

Reply on Twitter 1927426874210222315 Retweet on Twitter 1927426874210222315 1 Like on Twitter 1927426874210222315 1 Twitter 1927426874210222315
Load More

Copyright © 2008–2025 Big Ideas for Small Business, Inc  |  Designed by Hudson Fusion

  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap